Pages

Friday, July 19, 2013

Outgrowing Hope Part II: the problem with Santa Claus...and other musings about false hope

                
So in my last post I wrote a little bit about the significance of hope and about our senseless tendency  to outgrow it the way we outgrow nightlights or stuffed animals (For the record, I’ve only outgrown one of these two.).  I endorsed wild, childlike hope. Today I write about setting that wild hope in the right place and about the dangers of setting our hope in the wrong place.   

Let me refer to my last post again. Remember how I said that we’re programmed to hope? I think that everybody hopes in something. Notice I did not say “hopes for something.” You can hope for a short line at Starbucks or for sunshine on your day off: you’ll either get your wish…or you won’t.  But you hope in Christ, in material possessions, in your relationship status, etc. This hoping in (as opposed to hoping for) is a part of your identity; it dictates how you live. For example, if your hope is in possessions, you live to acquire. If your hope is in Christ, you live to love. If your hope is in your relationship status, you might live to be loved, or to be independent and unattached (depending on the desired status), at all costs.  Really, this world offers us an abundance of places to set our hope.  However, each of these, but for Christ, is unsafe and only damages a childlike hope.

Bear with me for this illustration: Santa Claus. *Permission to roll eyes granted* When I was small, my calendar year revolved around Christmas Day and my sense of morality was grounded in the naughty and nice lists. When I was told just days before my eighth Christmas that Santa was a myth, that my loving parents were the ones responsible for the piles of packages under the pine tree, I was rocked. I know this sounds melodramatic, however at the time it seemed that my entire worldview had toppled. I remember timidly sitting down on my mother’s side of the bed that evening and, with a knot in my stomach and a voice softer than my usual, asking if it was true that Santa was not real. In one short sentence, my hopes for Christmas morning were gone.  Oh I would still receive presents, but the magic was no more. The excitement, the anticipation, the thrill had disappeared with my mother’s truthful answer. I recall that particular Christmas morning being tough. What was the point, after all? Yes, I got the doll house I’d wanted. But I got it because my parents saw me circle it with a yellow highlighter in the catalog and not because Santa Claus just knew.

It took me a couple Santa-less Christmases before I could appreciate the holiday the way I had before. As I grew older and learned more about why Christmas is really worth celebrating, as my hopes shifted from Santa Claus to Immanuel, I became convinced that the lie of Santa, the hollow hope I’d clung to, had been damaging. It had shaken my faith in my parents firstly, but it had also left some part of me wondering if any hope at all was safe. If Santa’s not real...what else? Well turns out, the Tooth Fairy and the Easter Bunny, for starters.

As I continued growing, I placed my hopes in other unsafe places, like in the approval of boys. I repeatedly found my joy and my identity in winning affirmation from the opposite sex. But like all false hopes, these tumbled again and again. After each disappointing relationship I asked myself the same question I’d asked as a young child: Is any hope safe?  If his love wasn’t real…what else? For a few years I was caught in a cycle: receiving and hoping in affection from a boy, seeing this affection prove false or fleeting, then experiencing deep disappointment…and then repeating it all out of desperate longing to see hope win. I’d say it was only about a year and a half ago, if I’m being perfectly honest, that I began to realize where my misplaced hopes really belonged.

While I was studying abroad in Ireland in the spring of 2012, one of my classmates had anonymously slipped a brief note into my mailbox. A few encouraging words were scrawled across a piece of torn-out notebook paper and the last lines read “keep seeking. Memorize- Romans 5:5.” I grabbed my Bible and thumbed over the silvery pages until I found the passage, which read:
And hope does not disappoint us, because God has poured his love into our hearts by the Holy Spirit, whom he has given us.
There, sitting on the porch outside the kitchen door, gazing up at those green hills tumbling into the Irish Sea, something changed for me. A hope that doesn’t disappoint. The Holy Spirit whispered to me, “this is what you’ve been looking for. Right here. This is it.” And there was joy of the purest kind, the joy of a soul who is finally through playing hide and seek.  No more empty closets or bathtubs, as she finds herself face to face with the One for whom she’s been searching. I saw in a fresh way how silly I had been to place my hope, my identity in anyone besides my loving Savior, the Redeemer of my soul. I smiled.

This is where we are to put our wild, childlike hope- in Christ Jesus. When we place our hope in people or things other than Christ, we will eventually know bitter disappointment. But when our hope is in Jesus, we can face disappointing circumstances without being crushed. We can face ugly situations without being destroyed. We can know joy deep in our souls in even the grimmest of conditions, because we have a hope that does not disappoint.